Sometimes, cobbled together solutions from everyday folks can make a designer’s job a little easier.
I have lost every gym locker I have ever owned. They don’t let you keep it on a locker overnight at most gyms and health clubs, so you have to bring it back and forth every time. And it’s just small enough and just forgettable enough to be misplaced or lost when you’re throwing your gear together in the morning.
But for some reason, at the Downtown Pittsburgh YMCA, they’ve all figured it out. Everyone just snaps their lock to these beat-up, otherwise unusable shelves. It’s such a simple idea, and almost obvious in retrospect, but I’ve never seen it anywhere else.
What makes this interesting to me as a designer of complex systems is that the person who made that shelf couldn’t possibly have anticipated that it would be used this way. In fact…it is no longer a shelf…it’s a lock rack now. And we’re talking about shelves and masterlocks here, relatively simple creations.
No amount of thoughtful design can prevent resourceful people from using it in a way that serves their needs.
From a research perspective…little stuff like this can reveal opportunities for design. The way people “hack” their environments in clever ways often brings to the surface needs we didn’t know we had. If you asked 15,000 people at the gym “What do you need at the gym?” I’ll bet you $1000 that exactly 0 of them would say “a lock rack.” But as soon as one person starts using a shelf that way, everybody else in the whole YMCA is suddenly a customer.
If you took this exact same shelf, and called it a “lock rack,” and sold it as such, you would probably make money.
Sometimes, cobbled together solutions from everyday folks can make a designer’s job a little easier.
PS Try to take a camera phone picture in a locker room sometime. It doesn't go over well.